ANCAPS
ANARCHO-CAPITALISTS
Bitch-Slapping Statists For Fun & Profit Since 2007 |
| | Anarchism is Anti-Freedom, Anti-Capitalism, Anti-Life |    |
| | Goto page : 1, 2, 3 | | Author | Message |
|---|
CovOps
Age : 42
Joined : 27 Oct 2007
Posts : 5349
Location : Ether-Sphere
Job/hobbies : Irrationality Exterminator
Humor : Uber Serious
|  Subject: Re: Anarchism is Anti-Freedom, Anti-Capitalism, Anti-Life  Thu Mar 06, 2008 2:05 am | |
| Geezus!
You're equivocating to blue blazes! We won't play linguistic games.
You're rejecting a valid analysis, you're rejecting essential attributes, in other words, you're rejecting reason, so that you may stay wedded to your dogmatic prejudices. Shame...
If you seek justice, law is not the place for it and it never was. It is an instrument of oppression. But since you're not open to reason, here's a suggestion: Anytime you're evaluating any idea, first try and see how it would implement with just you and another person on a desert island. This will give you an inkling into how it will play out in a larger society.
In the case of "Laws" ie. oppressive edicts, it would work out as follows: There's only you and me on this island... and I just decided to implement "laws" which you are obliged to be subservient to... or else! Now, how "just" does that strike you as? I'll be the "lawgiver" and you'll be the "lawtaker." Doesn't sound too good does it? And it doesn't, because it isn't... be it between just us two... or even a few billion people...
_________________
"Taking money without permission is stealing unless you work for the IRS then it's taxation. Killing people en masse is homicidal mania unless you work for the Army then it's National Defense. Spying on your neighbors is invasion of privacy unless you work for the FBI then it's National Security. Running a whorehouse makes you a pimp & poisoning people makes you a murderer unless you work for the CIA then it's counter intelligence." R. Wilson. ANCAPS Forum Headquarters, Ancapolis |
|  | | andrergsanchez
Joined : 03 Mar 2008
Posts : 51
| | Subject: Re: Anarchism is Anti-Freedom, Anti-Capitalism, Anti-Life Thu Mar 06, 2008 2:45 am | |
| | Quote: | | But since you're not open to reason, |
I am.
| Quote: | | here's a suggestion: Anytime you're evaluating any idea, first try and see how it would implement with just you and another person on a desert island. This will give you an inkling into how it will play out in a larger society. |
Yes.
| Quote: |
In the case of "Laws" ie. oppressive edicts, it would work out as follows: There's only you and me on this island... and I just decided to implement "laws" which you are obliged to be subservient to... or else! |
As have I.
| Quote: |
Now, how "just" does that strike you as?
|
Depends on what the laws are. Are they just laws, or unjust laws?
| Quote: |
I'll be the "lawgiver" and you'll be the "lawtaker."
|
Is that so?
| Quote: |
Doesn't sound too good does it? And it doesn't, because it isn't... be it between just us two... or even a few billion people...
|
Listen... I cannot control your decisions. I can only control -my- decisions. And my decision would be to make a law, that if you threatened my life, the penalty would be death. My laws exist to protect me from you. If I could just wave a magic wand and make you respect my rights, I suppose I wouldn't need laws. |
| | | | CovOps
Age : 42
Joined : 27 Oct 2007
Posts : 5349
Location : Ether-Sphere
Job/hobbies : Irrationality Exterminator
Humor : Uber Serious
| | Subject: Re: Anarchism is Anti-Freedom, Anti-Capitalism, Anti-Life Thu Mar 06, 2008 2:58 am | |
| Wait a cotton picking minute here... what's this you just smuggled in:
| Quote: | In the case of "Laws" ie. oppressive edicts, it would work out as follows: There's only you and me on this island... and I just decided to implement "laws" which you are obliged to be subservient to... or else!
As have I. |
No sunshine, there's only one law (mine) and I administer it... just like in every state. And since you're not above the law, your only job is to obey my oppressive edicts... I'll even call them "laws" just so you feel better about them... As for are they just, unjust, half just, etc..? Well... as they say:" "Yours is not to reason why, yours is to obey and die!"
You still in favor of "laws?"
_________________
"Taking money without permission is stealing unless you work for the IRS then it's taxation. Killing people en masse is homicidal mania unless you work for the Army then it's National Defense. Spying on your neighbors is invasion of privacy unless you work for the FBI then it's National Security. Running a whorehouse makes you a pimp & poisoning people makes you a murderer unless you work for the CIA then it's counter intelligence." R. Wilson. ANCAPS Forum Headquarters, Ancapolis |
| | | | andrergsanchez
Joined : 03 Mar 2008
Posts : 51
| | Subject: Re: Anarchism is Anti-Freedom, Anti-Capitalism, Anti-Life Thu Mar 06, 2008 3:14 am | |
| | CovOps wrote: | Wait a cotton picking minute here... what's this you just smuggled in:
| Quote: | In the case of "Laws" ie. oppressive edicts, it would work out as follows: There's only you and me on this island... and I just decided to implement "laws" which you are obliged to be subservient to... or else!
As have I. |
No sunshine, there's only one law (mine) and I administer it... just like in every state. And since you're not above the law, your only job is to obey my oppressive edicts... I'll even call them "laws" just so you feel better about them... As for are they just, unjust, half just, etc..? Well... as they say:" "Yours is not to reason why, yours is to obey and die!"
You still in favor of "laws?" |
If you don't even understand the concept of "laws", why am I trying to debate with you? |
| | | | CovOps
Age : 42
Joined : 27 Oct 2007
Posts : 5349
Location : Ether-Sphere
Job/hobbies : Irrationality Exterminator
Humor : Uber Serious
| | Subject: Re: Anarchism is Anti-Freedom, Anti-Capitalism, Anti-Life Thu Mar 06, 2008 4:10 am | |
| It's pretty silly to try and patronize me, especially when the real lack of understanding, is flooding from your direction.
The example used is to illustrate the operation of "laws" but only in a limited context of one on one. And just like the state has a monopoly on "laws," so too, on the island, I had it as well.
And just as you don't have "your laws" in a state, so too, you don't have them on the island.
The end result is the same: Two classes of people, the lawmaker and the lawtaker. Now that we have the hierarchy established, you only need to obey... or else!
Not a pretty sight, is it?
_________________
"Taking money without permission is stealing unless you work for the IRS then it's taxation. Killing people en masse is homicidal mania unless you work for the Army then it's National Defense. Spying on your neighbors is invasion of privacy unless you work for the FBI then it's National Security. Running a whorehouse makes you a pimp & poisoning people makes you a murderer unless you work for the CIA then it's counter intelligence." R. Wilson. ANCAPS Forum Headquarters, Ancapolis |
| | | | Nemo
Joined : 26 Dec 2007
Posts : 2681
Location : Mariana Trench -- Hey Feds!! Come and get me!!
Humor : Black
| | Subject: Re: Anarchism is Anti-Freedom, Anti-Capitalism, Anti-Life Mon Mar 10, 2008 1:28 am | |
| The verbal beatings will continue until morale improves.
_________________
 Aquarchy Rules. Liquidate the Reds
ANCAPS Forum, Ancapolis, Aqua-Terra Atlantis Division. |
| | | | CovOps
Age : 42
Joined : 27 Oct 2007
Posts : 5349
Location : Ether-Sphere
Job/hobbies : Irrationality Exterminator
Humor : Uber Serious
| | Subject: Re: Anarchism is Anti-Freedom, Anti-Capitalism, Anti-Life Mon Mar 10, 2008 7:25 am | |
| 
_________________
"Taking money without permission is stealing unless you work for the IRS then it's taxation. Killing people en masse is homicidal mania unless you work for the Army then it's National Defense. Spying on your neighbors is invasion of privacy unless you work for the FBI then it's National Security. Running a whorehouse makes you a pimp & poisoning people makes you a murderer unless you work for the CIA then it's counter intelligence." R. Wilson. ANCAPS Forum Headquarters, Ancapolis |
| | | | | Anarchism is Anti-Freedom, Anti-Capitalism, Anti-Life | |
|
| Page 3 of 3 | Goto page : 1, 2, 3 |
| | Permissions of this forum: | You cannot reply to topics in this forum
| | |
|
|
|
